Joseph's Gallery of Pies

Our award winning lineup of pies makes choosing dessert easier than ever!

Each pie is prepared fresh daily in our own in-store bakery. And don't forget the sundaes and ice cream!

Pricing is available below the gallery.

Please select a thumbnail to see a larger version.

Dutch Apple

Rhubarb Custard

Pecan

Pumpkin

Sour Cream Raisin

Rhubarb Delight

Chocolate Carmel Supreme

Apple

Cherry

French Silk

Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake

Strawberry

Lemon Meringue

Blueberry Cheesecake

Cherry Cheesecake

Strawberry Cheesecake

Chocolate Raspberry Supreme

Coconut Cream

German Chocolate

Chocolate Cream

Banana Cream

Pies By The Slice

You said how wonderful our pies are, however, you were just too full for a whole slice... well, we are all about pleasing the customer so now the best pie in Stillwater is now available by the ½ slice for 3.29
* in season only -- We use real whipped cream
-- make any pie A la mode for 1.99 more

Specialty Pies

Chocolate Caramel Supreme ~ * Strawberry
* Strawberry Rhubarb ~ Sour Cream Raisin
French Silk ~ Lemon Meringue ~ * Peach Cream
whole pie 16.99 slice 4.29

Cheesecakes

Joseph's Style Cheesecake
(Cherry ~ Blueberry ~ Raspberry)
* Strawberry... in season
whole pie 16.99 slice 4.29

Grandma's Favorites

Dutch Apple ~ Pecan
Rhubarb Custard ~ * Pumpkin
Cherry ~ Blueberry ~ Cherry Crumb
whole pie 14.99 slice 3.79

Cream Pies

Lemon ~ Coconut ~ Banana ~ Chocolate
Macadamia Nut ~ German Chocolate
whole pie 14.99 slice 3.79

Lumberjack Days pie baking Contest Winners

Barb's Pecan Surprise ~ Mary Sue's Raspberry Swirl
Apple ~ Mary Lou's Rhubarb Delight
Mary Lou's Millionaires Pie ~ Laurie's Heathbar
Lisa's Cookies & Cream ~ Papa Luke's Peanut Butter
Sherri's Raspberry Cream
Mary Jo's Chocolate Raspberry Supreme
Mary Jo's Fruited Cream Cheese
Nancy's Just Cheesecake ~ Brenna's Chocolate Chip Cheese
Caelie's Strawberry Blossom ~ Brenna's Chocolate Cheesecake
whole pie 16.99 slice 4.29

Malts & Shakes

smooth and creamy... your choice of hot
fudge, chocolate or strawberry 5.49

Ice Cream

hand dipped vanilla or cinnamon ice cream
one big scoop 2.99 two big scoops 3.99

Sundaes

two scoops of vanilla ice cream with your choice of hot fudge, chocolate
or strawberry topping 4.99 one scoop sundae 3.99